Rapid Prototyping: Subtractive vs. Additive

by | Feb 16, 2017 | Blog

12 min read
With additive manufacturing and 3D printers being such a hot topic these days, it’s important to remember why subtractive processes like milling are still incredibly important to rapid prototyping. But first, let’s examine some of the benefits and limitations of additive rapid prototyping (or direct digital manufacturing).

Benefits of Additive Rapid Prototyping

The process of additive rapid prototyping joins and fuses materials like liquid resins together, layer upon layer to produce a 3D object from model data. Additive rapid prototyping is generally simple, relatively inexpensive and fast. Additive rapid prototyping also allows for a substantial amount of complexity within cavities or internal areas of a part that would require undercuts and may even be impossible with subtractive processes like milling.

Limitations of Additive Rapid Prototyping

The primary drawback of additive rapid prototyping is that the resulting part usually is not made of an end-use material like metal … and even if it is, it lacks structural integrity. That’s because the point where one layer is joined to another lacks the physical strength exhibited by a solid block of the same material (with no layers or joints).

Subtractive Rapid Prototyping with End-Use Materials

Subtractive rapid prototyping provides the ability to prototype in end-use materials. Since milling or machining removes material from a larger piece of material, the finished part has a solid composition rather than a layered composition as seen in additive rapid prototyping with 3D printers. This yields a higher structural integrity which is critical if the prototype part is to be used in product testing. Product testing with a part made through subtractive prototyping allows for an accurate analysis of the part’s viability and even durability since it is made from the same material that will be used to manufacture production parts.

A Wider Range of Surface Finishes and Textures with Subtractive Prototyping

Subtractive rapid prototyping processes also offer a wider range of surface finishes for the completed prototype as opposed to the standard “stepped finish” often achieved in additive rapid prototyping with a 3D printer. This could range from a completely smooth surface with a mirror-like finish to ones with milled or engraved textures. In this way, subtractive rapid prototyping with a high speed CNC milling machine is capable of producing prototype parts with a repeatability suitable for end-use production. The smooth surface finish that can be achieved with high-speed machining can be functionally beneficial if the given part needs to slide and aesthetically beneficial if the prototype is going to be used in market testing.

Additive Rapid Prototyping vs. Subtractive Rapid Prototyping

To illustrate the points made above, we asked our applications engineers to quickly prototype a part using both additive and subtractive processes. Since our favorite after-hours (wink, wink) past time is foosball, they decided to make a “replacement” foosball man for testing. This decision was based on an actual real-life need – since we had recently broken one of the men that came with our vintage 1985 foosball table. Using additive rapid prototyping (3D printing), they were able to design a very rudimentary foosball man in about 90 minutes. From there, they began printing and in just over an hour the part seen below was complete.

 

Additive rapid prototype made with a 3D printer to compare to a similar subtractive rapid prototype made with a high speed milling machine.

Additive rapid prototype made with a 3D printer shows the typical stepped finish indicative of this process.

 

Using subtractive rapid prototyping (high-speed milling) programming the part took substantially longer and clocked in at 3 hrs. 45 minutes. However, milling the part below was considerably faster than 3D printing and took 28 minutes.

 

Subtractive rapid prototyping processes like machining tend to offer more flexibility in terms of surface finish as well as the ability to prototype in end-use materials that are superior for product testing.

Subtractive rapid prototype showing a smooth surface finish and a solid composition that delivered greater functionality.

 

Product Testing an Additive Rapid Prototype vs. a Subtractive Rapid Prototype

Well, you knew we had to “test” the part right? So, in a series of 4 rather heated games using each prototype, here’s what we found. In terms of functionality and durability, the subtractive prototype was the clear winner. Not only did it last through the 4 games, the solid composition of the part made for stronger shots with high velocity. Plus, it clearly would hold up for hundreds of more games. By comparison, the 3D printed part began to show signs of delamination on its right side half way through game 3 — and by the game 4 we had to mend it with a bit of scotch tape to get through the rest of our “product testing”. The damage to the part revealed the inside composition of the 3D printed part as seen below.

 

Additive rapid prototyping using 3D printing can be fast, but less functional in terms of product or market testing due to both aesthetics and their non-solid composition.

Cross section of 3D printing prototype shows internal construction.

 

The rather hollow nature of this part shined a bit of light on why we couldn’t achieve strong shots using this foosball man. In analyzing the resulting surface finish on both parts, we felt that the subtractive prototype was … well, simply more attractive. Plus, the milling process provided more flexibility to achieve different surface finishes. For example, we were able to make the majority of the subtractive prototype very smooth while giving the foot section a more textured finish for added “grip” or ball control. By contrast, the inherent “stepped” surface finish on the additive prototype served well in terms of ball control … but wasn’t very attractive over the entire part.

The Ultimate Subtractive Rapid Prototyping CNC Machine:

Last year’s introduction of the DATRON neo compact high-speed milling machine makes subtractive rapid prototyping more affordable and viable than ever. Plus it’s compact size and touchscreen operation make it easy to use and easy to fit in the tightest “lab-type” environment.

About DATRON

High-Speed CNC machining is more than 60,000 RPM spindle-speed. When you’re making small or complex parts, you need speed and precision at every stage. DATRON AG engineers didn’t just invest a faster, more precise spindle. They re-interpreted and optimized your entire machining workflow from start to finish.

About the Author

DATRON Archives

DATRON Twitter Feed

How do you quickly produce precision parts in a clean space environment like a lab? By choosing a compact, easy to use solution to produce parts without waste fluids.

Watch the first of two videos of a microfluidics piece coming directly off of an M8Cube machine.

Having difficulties balancing a diverse range of applications & of materials? Find out how successful shops are tackling these challenges & the benefits of high speed milling on Episode 8 of The Job Shop Podcast.

Learn more: http://bit.ly/2LHyyFS

#datron #thejobshopshow

Did you know that a camera is different than a vision system? Cameras are used for manual alignments and setup assistance while a vision system can automatically recognize a part with repeatable visual indicators.

Learn more: http://bit.ly/2ORghry and http://bit.ly/33QV9pG

Maybe riding the longboard to work today was a bad choice...

http://bit.ly/34Hj5NA

#datron #snowstorm #longboard #m10pro

Hope that the turkey hasn't made you too slee.....zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Happy Thanksgiving from all of us at DATRON Dynamics!

#datron #turkeytime #MLCube #happythanksgiving #gobblegobble #instamachinist #nomnom

2

Since we were up putting the turkey in the oven this morning, we thought we'd do a little holiday engraving. Happy Thanksgiving from all of us at DATRON Dynamics!

#datron #turkeytime #MLCube #happythanksgiving #gobblegobble #instamachinist #nomnom

Did you miss the Tech Tidbit on Monday? Let us fill you in.

A large flute and balanced design can lead to more efficient milling which can impact the quality of your finished product and your machines spindle life. Learn more http://bit.ly/2shMmjy

#datron #datrontools

Can't visit California, Boston, New Hampshire, San Francisco, Chicago, or Toronto to see DATRON in person? We bring the technology to you! Our live video cart broadcast our controller, milling going on inside the machine, and allow for Q&A...all live! https://bit.ly/2npcYdg

Are you milling in a low volume, high mix environment or milling composite materials like ABS, acrylic, carbon fiber, or TFA? Watch Mirotech thrive in that exact enviroment with the Arboron test fixture.

#datron #highspeedmilling #compositemilling #mirotech #instamachinist

High-frequency forming can be used to create 3-dimensional products that look like a high-sheen metal. Unfortunately, any imperfection can destroy the illusion. Learn how Dec-O-Art solved this exact issue .

http://bit.ly/2XadEnv

#datron #highspeedmilling #decoform

Load More...

Discover How You Can Revolutionize Your Entire Workflow Today

DATRON machines dramatically reduce practically every aspect of your machining workflow. Download our FREE Workflow Optimization Map and learn how today.